Case Study: Guilty or Not Guilty: Does It Matter?
Dr. Jennifer Bauer has been asked by the defense attorney to assist in jury selection. The defendant is a battered wife who has been accused of murdering her abusive husband one night when he was drunk and became verbally abusive.
The defense attorney has also hired a prominent psychiatrist who has suggested that the defense attorney use the battered woman syndrome as a defense strategy. Dr. Bauer thinks that this is a poor decision since the syndrome evidence has not been very successful in court cases, and she believes that the argument would be more successful using posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) as a defense. However, she was hired to assist in jury selection and not to help develop the defense strategy. Additionally, the psychiatrist retained by the attorney has developed a career arguing the syndrome evidence in courts and is not very receptive to criticism.
After it has been determined by the court that Dr. Bauer can be an expert witness (voir dire), she reads through the discovery materials, including the evidence provided by the defense and the prosecution. Despite her empathy for battered women, Dr. Bauer feels that the weak defense strategy along with the strong evidence against the defendant will lead to a guilty verdict for the defendant. In fact, after reviewing the documentation in the case, Dr. Bauer thinks that the defendant is guilty of manslaughter.
During the voir dire process, Dr. Bauer decides that many of the potential jurors are not sympathetic toward the defendant. She decides that the only possibility is to hope for a mistrial by employing the poison pill strategy. She hopes to select jurors whose strong personality differences make them clash so much during the deliberations that they are unable to come to a unanimous verdict.
In a minimum of 250 words, analyze the case study and address the following:
- How should Dr. Bauer proceed? Provide reasons to support your answer.
- Should she offer her advice regarding the syndrome evidence? Why or why not?
- Should she pursue the poison pill strategy? Why or why not?
- By Saturday, October 4, 2014, post your responses to this Discussion Area.
- Through Wednesday, October 8, 2014, respond to at least two other classmates’ posts. Participate in the discussion by asking a question, providing a statement of clarification, providing a point of view with a rationale, challenging an aspect of the discussion, or indicating a relationship between two or more lines of reasoning in the discussion.
The post 250 Word Discussion appeared first on nursing Writers.
“Looking for a Similar Assignment? Get Expert Help at an Amazing Discount!”
250 Word Discussion was first posted on August 2, 2019 at 2:04 pm.
©2019 “nursing Writers”. Use of this feed is for personal non-commercial use only. If you are not reading this article in your feed reader, then the site is guilty of copyright infringement. Please contact me at