# Coyne and Messina Articles: Part 1 – Analysis

In a paper (1,000-1,250 words), compare and contrast the major elements of the assigned articles by Coyne et al. and Messina et al.

See the “Coyne and Messina Articles Analysis” as a resource. Study the information in the right-side column related to the Coyne et al. study, which identifies the required elements as found in the reading. Complete the information for the Messina et al. article by identifying the required elements from the article.

Prepare this assignment according to the guidelines found in the APA Style Guide, located in the Student Success Center. An abstract is not required.

This assignment uses a rubric. Please review the rubric prior to beginning the assignment to become familiar with the expectations for successful completion.

You are required to submit this assignment to LopesWrite. Please refer to the directions in the Student Success Center.

Coyne and Messina Articles Analysis

As an example guideline, review the study components in the left-side column of the table below. Read the study by Messina et al., and build the data in the right-side column with the key components in that study.

 Research Question: Coyne: Do size and ownership type make a difference in the efficiency and cost results of hospitals in Washington state? (Highlight p.164, second column, starting 15 lines from bottom to seven lines from bottom.) Messina: How did the research question emerge from the review of literature in the article? Coyne: Built on an earlier study by Coyne on performance differences between multi-facility systems and independent hospitals using two cost measures. Cited studies that used a range of variables to measure differences in hospital performance, and noted that prior findings have been inconclusive in regard to hospital size, although economies of scale were found. Messina: Independent Variables Type: Coyne: Hospital size and hospital ownership structure. Categorical Messina: Dependent Variables Type: Coyne: Efficiency measures – continuous variables. Cost measures – continuous variables. Messina: Design Elements 1. Quantitative vs. Qualitative 2. Sample Size 3. Method of sample selection 4. Experimental vs. control group? 5. Reliable and valid data instruments? Coyne: Quantitative 96 Picked all hospitals in state, except investor owned hospitals. No Used data that are commonly used to measure hospital efficiency and performance with high degrees of accuracy (reliable), and data that are historically used and make sense to other hospital users (valid). Messina: Describe analysis. What statistics were used? Coyne: Two-way Analysis of Variance (ANOVA) Messina: Did the researchers’ conclusions make sense, did they answer the research question, and did they appear to flow from the review of the literature? Did they explore control of extraneous variables? Coyne: They concluded that size and ownership type make a difference in reported levels of efficiency. Not for profits seem to achieve higher performance levels, and medium and large not for profits operate more efficiently than industry average. The same results were found for cost levels, in that size and ownership type do make a difference, with medium sized hospitals reporting lower costs than large or small hospitals. Yes, when they called for national studies that controlled for case mix, scope of services, and payer mix, all of which could have affected the results in this study in an unmeasured way. Messina:

## Does this Look Like Your Assignment? We Can do an Original Paper for you!

### Have some Questions? Here's Some Answers

A Page will cost you \$12, however, this varies with your deadline.

Enjoy the convenience of having a reliable Writer to do your paper at an Affordable Price.  With our premium writing service, you no longer have to spend days and nights meticulously working on your assignment, instead use that time to do other important things.

Upon completion, we will send the paper to you via email and in the format you prefer (word, pdf or ppt).

Yes, we have an unlimited revision policy. If you need a comma removed, we will do that for you in less than 6 hours, if you need a full paper review we are always available to handle your request.

As you Share your instructions with us, there’s a section that allows you to attach as any files. Please include all the details and files useful to the writer. You can also provide a sample of your work, so that the writer can write just like you!

Yes, through email and messages, we will keep you updated on the progress of your paper.